MediumVII Reinsurance & Specialty Risk12 November 2026, Thursday
Back-to-back earthquakes are eroding reinsurance limits in Latin America
Lucas Castagnino, MS Re's chief underwriter for Latin America, said on 12 November that the region had seen four earthquakes of magnitude 7 or above in three months. In his view it is accumulation, not individual events, that is exhausting limits and reinstatements. Munich Re alone set aside about €300 million for the El Choco earthquake.
Castagnino's warning is aimed at programme design. Many reinsurance programmes in the region were built on the assumption of one catastrophe a year; four quakes of magnitude 7 or above in three months across South and Central America and Mexico put that assumption under strain. A reinstatement premium is the additional charge paid to restore an exhausted limit. Castagnino said these premiums could put extra pressure on insurers' capital under risk-based capital regimes.
The losses are tangible. According to Munich Re's results on 12 November, the costliest item in its €514 million of third-quarter natural catastrophe losses was the El Choco earthquake in Colombia, at about €300 million. Over the same period Paraguay was hit by hail of 5–10 centimetres, and the Itaipu and Yacyretá dams reached peak water levels in October and opened their spillways. Castagnino expects flood risk to peak in December–February; Hurricane Melissa in 2025 left Jamaica with damage of about $12 billion, more than half of GDP.
Our reading is that global capacity is plentiful, but in Latin America the constraint is structure, not price. Castagnino said reinsurance capital remained abundant, but that the loss burden being ceded would affect pricing and capacity. If demand for aggregate excess-of-loss and reinstatement protection rises at the January renewal, cost will shift from per-event layers to aggregate layers.
Talay assessment
Bottom line
In Latin America the global softening and local loss frequency are pulling in opposite directions. Per-event layers are getting cheaper while aggregate protection is becoming more valuable. The most likely path is that regional prices fall less than the broader market at 1 January and reinsurers become tougher in selecting clients.
Likely effects
- Regional reinsurance pricingNegativeWeeks
Back-to-back earthquakes and the flood season erase part of the global rate cut on property catastrophe programmes in the region.
- Insurer capitalNegative1–6 months
Reinstatement premiums and exhausted limits drag down local insurers' capital ratios in countries applying risk-based capital regimes.
- Programme structureUncertain1–6 months
Demand for aggregate excess-of-loss and reinstatement protection rises, opening a higher-margin but capacity-constrained segment for reinsurers.
Possibilities, ranked
- 1Selective renewal55%
Capacity is found in January, but cedents with poor loss records renew with higher retentions and limited reinstatements.
Watch: The Latin America line in broker reports in early January
- 2Flood season hardens the picture30%
December–February floods create fresh accumulation, and some programmes need to buy extra cover mid-year.
Watch: Flood loss reports from Paraguay and Brazil
- 3Global softening prevails15%
Abundant capital absorbs regional losses without pricing them in, and cuts land close to the global average.
Watch: Regional cedents' disclosures on 1 January price changes
Probabilities are calibrated judgement based on the sources, not measurement, and are revised as new information arrives. Not investment advice.
Market reaction
Indicators affected
- M7+ quakes (in 3 months)▼ 4
- El Choco loss, Munich Re▼ ~€300m
- Q3 nat cat losses (MR)▼ €514m
Sources
- Reinsurance News — Cat loss accumulation could test LatAm insurers' resilience, says MS Re's Castagnino (12 November 2026)
- Artemis — Munich Re's P&C reinsurance sees decline in Q3, while net result rises to €5.7bn for 9M'26 (12 November 2026)
- Insurance Business — Munich Re raises profit target as L&H growth offsets P&C softening (12 November 2026)