MediumIII Kinetic Conflicts & Defence15 November 2026, Sunday
ASEAN and China miss 2026 target for South China Sea code
Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said at the 49th ASEAN Summit in Manila on 15 November that the South China Sea code of conduct had not been concluded under the Philippine chairmanship. Provisional agreement covers about 80% of the draft.
In 2023 foreign ministers pledged to finish the code within three years, that is, in 2026, when the Philippines holds the chair. Negotiations have dragged on for more than 20 years, and delegations met at least once a month during the Philippine term. Lazaro said on 15 November that there was no outcome yet. The task now passes to Singapore, which takes over the chair in 2027.
The open articles go to the heart of the code. The first is whether the text will be legally binding. The second is geographic scope: China claims almost the entire sea and does not recognise the 2016 arbitration ruling. The exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam overlap with that claim. The Philippines also wants the code to respect the rights of countries outside the region.
The constraint lies in ASEAN's decision-making method. The code requires the consensus of every ASEAN member and China, so a strong text is vetoed by Beijing and a weak one by Manila. Tensions escalated in the run-up to the summit. In September, Defence Secretary Gilberto Teodoro responded to a note attributed to China's military attaché in Seoul. In October, China's ambassador in Manila, Jing Quan, said China could easily win if it used force. China sent only its attaché to the defence ministers' meeting in Cebu at the end of October.
According to Al Jazeera, half of the world's merchant ships pass through the South China Sea. Premier Li Qiang's attendance at the Manila summit on 15 November shows that diplomacy has not broken down. Analysts say the agenda is shifting towards protectionism and supply chain problems, which makes the code even harder to reach.
Talay assessment
Bottom line
Missing the 2026 target means there will be no common rulebook to manage tensions on the water in the South China Sea for at least another year. Some 80% of the draft is ready, but the remaining 20% holds the core issues of bindingness and scope. The most likely path is that talks continue under Singapore's chairmanship and the text is watered down into a non-binding framework.
Likely effects
- Philippines–China relationsNegative1–6 months
Without a code, incidents such as water-cannon attacks and collisions stay at the bilateral level, with no common mechanism to limit escalation.
- Maritime tradeNegative6 months+
The failure to agree a rules-based framework in waters carrying half the world's merchant ships leaves route risk politically open.
- ASEAN cohesionUncertain1–6 months
Singapore takes over the file in 2027, and its profile as a mediator could pull the talks onto more technical ground.
Possibilities, ranked
- 1Talks continue under Singapore60%
Negotiations run on in 2027 with the same open articles, and the dispute over bindingness remains unresolved.
Watch: The place of the code of conduct in Singapore's priorities for its 2027 chairmanship
- 2Quick non-binding text25%
The parties drop bindingness, settle for a political document and sign it in the first half of 2027.
Watch: A statement from an ASEAN–China senior officials' meeting that the binding clause has been abandoned
- 3Escalation freezes talks15%
A fresh collision at Scarborough or during resupply missions forces the talks to be suspended.
Watch: A new water-cannon or collision report from the Philippine Coast Guard
Probabilities are calibrated judgement based on the sources, not measurement, and are revised as new information arrives. Not investment advice.
Market reaction
Indicators affected
- Share of draft agreed▲ 80%
- Length of negotiations▼ 20+ years