Skip to content
RegionEurope

LowVII Reinsurance & Specialty Risk13 November 2026, Friday

JP Morgan warns leveraged capital will push reinsurance rates lower still

In a note reported on 13 November, JP Morgan said the Cortina syndicate at Lloyd's, backed by Aon and Blackstone funds, brings additional capacity, and that additional capacity rarely helps pricing. The bank calculates that investors using 3–4 times investment leverage can target mid-teens returns even on thin technical margins.

Location: LONDON

According to Reinsurance News on 13 November, JP Morgan points to the 2013 Aon–Berkshire Hathaway deal as a precedent; that arrangement was also struck at the start of a soft market. The bank does not expect the new capital to sharpen competition straight away, but writes that if Cortina succeeds, other capital will follow. In the previous soft cycle, low interest rates made alternative capital less attractive. Today, with collateral assets earning high yields, backers can target mid-teens returns using 3–4 times investment leverage. Evercore ISI also sees similar structures as negative for reinsurers, because they add capacity to a limited pool of risk.

According to an Artemis analysis on 13 November, Cortina, Syndicate 1956, will automatically write 3% of eligible property catastrophe excess-of-loss treaties placed by Aon and 5% of other eligible treaties. The structure uses Lloyd's infrastructure and the London Bridge 2 protected cell company. At the PwC summit in Bermuda, Michael Millette of Hudson Structured said capital markets supply 140 billion dollars of the roughly 500 billion dollars of global catastrophe limit.

The Talay reading is that high rates are not drawing capital out of reinsurance; they are pulling it in through collateral yield. This capital does not set prices itself; according to JP Morgan, lead reinsurers set the terms. With fewer than 7 weeks to the 1 January 2027 renewal, that means follow capacity could deepen rate cuts in property catastrophe while lead desks put a floor under pricing.

Talay assessment

Bottom line

High rates are drawing new, cheap capital into reinsurance through collateral yield, and JP Morgan's 3–4 times leverage calculation shows the mechanism. Because this capital does not set prices, the most likely effect is deeper property catastrophe rate cuts on 1 January, with lead reinsurers holding the line on terms rather than volume.

Likely effects

  • Property cat reinsurance ratesPositiveWeeks

    As capacity that automatically follows the lead is added to treaties, cedants gain bargaining power; expectations of rate cuts on 1 January stretch further.

  • Lloyd's follow syndicatesNegative1–6 months

    Follow syndicates that cannot set prices now compete for the same business as corporate capital writing automatic 3–5% lines; premium flow and margins narrow.

  • TürkiyePositiveWeeks

    Ample, cheap catastrophe capacity eases Turkish insurers' price negotiations on 1 January earthquake treaties; selectivity persists in high-risk zones rather than upper layers.

Possibilities, ranked

  1. 1
    Follow capacity multiplies50%

    New broker vehicles similar to Cortina are announced, and 1 January property cat rate cuts approach the top end of broker expectations.

    Watch: New follow syndicate approvals at Lloyd's in December and broker renewal reports

  2. 2
    Impact stays limited35%

    The new capital remains small, lead reinsurers set the price and rate cuts stay within the expected band.

    Watch: Property cat rate changes in early-January broker reports

  3. 3
    Rate cuts weaken the pull15%

    If collateral yields fall, the leveraged return calculation breaks down and new capital inflows slow.

    Watch: A marked fall in US Treasury bill yields

Probabilities are calibrated judgement based on the sources, not measurement, and are revised as new information arrives. Not investment advice.

Market reaction

Indicators affected

  • Investment leverage (JP Morgan)▼ 3–4x
  • Cortina property cat share▼ 3%
  • Capital markets cat limit▲ ~$140bn

Sources

  1. Reinsurance News — Cortina launch raises fresh concerns over additional reinsurance capacity: JP Morgan (13 November 2026)
  2. Artemis — Cortina: Just a soft market trend, or clearing the floor for reinsurance's next act? (13 November 2026)
  3. Artemis — ILS seeks growth beyond property cat as investors explore new opportunities: PwC Insurance Summit (13 November 2026)
Share