Skip to content
RegionEurasia

HighIII Kinetic Conflicts & Defence14 November 2026, Saturday

US asked Ukraine to quit Donbas in exchange for NATO membership

Zelensky said on 14 November that US negotiators had for the first time tied NATO membership to territorial concessions. The question was whether Ukraine would withdraw from the parts of Donbas that Russia does not control. Zelensky said no, but left the door open to a referendum if a comprehensive package emerged.

Location: DONBAS

According to Al Jazeera, Zelensky said on 14 November that Ukraine would not accept neutrality, which would require a constitutional amendment. CBS reported that Kushner said the same day that the US was focused on establishing direct contact between Moscow and its European partners. Washington is drafting the agenda for the next trilateral round. The first US-brokered Ukraine–Russia talks since February ended on 11 November with a plan for a new prisoner exchange. At a summit in Ireland on 13 November, EU leaders settled on a five-country European team: the UK, France, Germany, Italy and Poland. Russian officials said roughly 1,200 Ukrainian drones were launched at Russia on 13 November.

The constraint is that the proposal puts on the table NATO membership, which Moscow has treated as a red line since 2022. Al Jazeera notes that Putin cited Ukraine's NATO ambitions as one of the justifications for the 2022 invasion. According to CBS, Trump will meet Putin and Xi at a three-way summit next week, and Ukraine is not expected to be on the agenda. Zelensky predicted that in security talks Putin would raise US troops in Finland, Sweden, Hungary and the Baltics. The war is now more than four and a half years old, and territory is being discussed in the same breath as alliance membership for the first time.

Talay assessment

Bottom line

Washington has for the first time bundled territory and alliance membership into a single package. Kyiv has rejected it, and Moscow has for years treated NATO membership as a red line, so the offer is unacceptable to both sides. The most likely path is that the proposal never becomes a formal text and the talks drift towards the wider European security order.

Likely effects

  • Peace talksNegative1–6 months

    If the talks shift from Ukrainian territory to the European security order, the process will lengthen and the odds of a near-term ceasefire will fall.

  • European defenceUncertainWeeks

    The EU's five-country team does not talk to Russia directly; Kushner's call for direct contact will test that limit.

  • TürkiyeUncertain1–6 months

    Türkiye is not on the European team; if Black Sea security reaches the table, Ankara's role will be redefined through the Turkish Straits.

Possibilities, ranked

  1. 1
    Proposal stays in limbo60%

    The parties carry out the prisoner exchange, and the territory and NATO questions are pushed to a later round.

    Watch: The date of the next trilateral round and implementation of the prisoner exchange

  2. 2
    Europe joins the table25%

    The European team makes its first direct contact with Moscow, and the agenda widens to European security.

    Watch: An announcement of a meeting between the European team and a Russian official

  3. 3
    Talks collapse15%

    Kyiv's rejection and Moscow's neutrality demand halt the talks amid a new wave of attacks.

    Watch: Russia announcing its withdrawal from the talks

Probabilities are calibrated judgement based on the sources, not measurement, and are revised as new information arrives. Not investment advice.

Market reaction

Indicators affected

  • European negotiating team▲ 5 countries
  • Drones launched at Russia (13 November)▼ 1,200

Sources

  1. Al Jazeera — US suggested Ukraine cede parts of Donbas to Russia to become part of NATO
  2. CBS News — US facilitating direct engagement between Europe and Russia amid push for peace in Ukraine, Kushner says
Share