
VII Reinsurance & Specialty Risk·Analysis·Europe
Reinsurance is getting cheaper, but attachment points are not coming down
Property catastrophe pricing is expected to fall about 10% at 1 January 2027, and cat bond spreads have dropped 21.6% in a year. Yet reinsurers are holding the attachment points they raised in 2023. That is why Europe's hail and flood losses stayed on the books of Generali and Zurich.
Talay Insight Editorial · 16 November 2026 · 6 min read · 13 sources
Talay Insight Analysis DeskAI-assisted analysis, reviewed by an editorPublisher of record: Lu Apps LLCTrack recordRequest a correction
Why it matters
Noise: reinsurance is cheaper everywhere; KBW expects property cat rates to fall about 10% at 1 January, and cat bond spreads are down to 5.05%. Signal: prices fall, attachment points do not. The attachment point is the loss level at which the reinsurer starts paying. Berenberg says holding it at 2023 levels is worth a 20–30% pricing edge, two to three times the discount. Result: the cat impact on Generali's combined ratio rose from 2.2 to 5.2 points. In war risk, the Black Sea premium hit 20%; trade returns at 2%.
Implications
- Reinsurance News reports that Generali's nine-month natural catastrophe losses reached 1.47 billion euros, lifting their impact on the combined ratio from 2.2 to 5.2 points in a year.
- Euler ILS data show the average cat bond spread fell 21.6% in a year to 5.05%; 64% of 2026 issuance clustered in the 1–3% expected-loss range.
- Beinsure says war-risk premiums on voyages to Novorossiysk have risen to 20% of hull value; analysts point to 2% as the threshold for a broad recovery.
Noise
Reinsurance is getting cheaper in every layer and the soft market is deepening
Signal
Attachment points stay at 2023 levels; the discount does not reach structure
The noise is in price, the signal in the threshold
The reinsurance market in November 2026 speaks with one headline: prices are falling. On 9 November KBW wrote that property catastrophe excess-of-loss rates would fall at least 10% at 1 January. The decline was 12% in January 2026 and 16% at mid-year. Euler ILS says the average cat bond spread has fallen 21.6% in a year to 5.05%.
Talay's reading: price is loosening, structure is not. The parameter that defines structure is the attachment point, the loss threshold at which the reinsurer starts paying. Reinsurers raised it in January 2023. Since then, frequent losses such as hail, flood and wildfire have stayed in the retention of the ceding insurer, the cedent. According to a September round-up by Actuary.info, Berenberg calculated that holding the threshold at 2023 levels gives reinsurers a 20–30% pricing advantage. The 10% discount on the table is less than half of that.
KBW's September warning points the same way: within the 10% expectation at Monte Carlo, upper layers fall further. Reinsurers are granting cheaper cover in remote layers, not in working layers. That distinction shows the issue is structure, not price. Who ends up holding the loss follows from that structure.
1 · The constraint: the discount is upstairs, the losses downstairs
Third-quarter results show who is holding the losses. On 13 November Generali reported 1.47 billion euros of natural catastrophe losses for nine months. That amount accounted for 5.2 points of the combined ratio, up from 2.2 points a year earlier. At Zurich, the catastrophe loss ratio in property and casualty rose from 1.4% to 3.2%. The company attributed the increase to hail and torrential rain in Germany, Italy and Switzerland. PERILS estimates insured losses from the Raphaela storms of 26–28 August at 3.296 billion euros.
Most of these losses never reached the reinsurance programme. Howden Re says reinsurers have carried 40% of natural catastrophe exposure since 2021 but paid less than 25% of 2025 losses. Reinsurers Berenberg met at Monte Carlo in September showed very limited appetite for frequency cover, the protection that absorbs frequent mid-sized losses. Rather than loosen terms, reinsurers chose to give ground on price.
Munich Re's chief financial officer called 1 January a challenging renewal on 12 November and offered no price forecast. Reinsurance News reports that clients and brokers now want to change terms as well as price. That threshold is precisely what the negotiation is about.
2 · Where the capital is flowing
Abundant capital is heading to remote layers. On 12 November the California Earthquake Authority upsized Ursa Re 2026-1 from 600 million to 900 million dollars. Class H, with an expected loss of 6.35%, is the authority's riskiest tranche; even so, price guidance fell from 8.5–9.5% to 8–8.25%. Euler ILS says 64% of 2026 issuance sits in the 1–3% expected-loss range, against 37% in 2018.
Investors earn a two-part return on this risk: the risk spread and the interest on collateral assets. The average coupon is 7.14% and the spread 5.05%. As long as policy rates stay high, total returns remain attractive even as spreads tighten. This capital is cheapening remote catastrophe layers, but it reaches lower layers and frequency risk only to a limited extent.
One exception is worth watching. Allied World's 2001 CAT Re 2026-1 deal targets 325 million dollars and moves from a per-occurrence to an annual aggregate basis. The Class A notes carry an attachment probability of 7.47% and price guidance of 9–9.5%. Bavarian insurer VKB also upsized its German multi-peril bond to 200 million euros on 11 November. Primary insurers are trying to plug the gap through the capital markets.
3 · On the war line, price shuts the door
In war risk the threshold is much clearer. A Beinsure round-up on 13 November says some ships bound for Novorossiysk were quoted war-risk premiums of 20% of hull value. Before 2022 the rate was 0.25–0.35%. Analysts say premiums need to fall to 2% for Black Sea trade to recover at scale. On a 40-million-dollar ship, 20% comes to 8 million dollars.
Cover is not formally withdrawn, but above 2% trade stops making economic sense. The Russian National Reinsurance Company offers an alternative, but can cover only 50–70 ships at a time. The one corridor below the threshold was Romanian and Bulgarian transit; ShipUniverse says quotes there were in a 0.4–1% band on 9 November. Euronews reports that four commercial ships were struck by drones in that corridor, off the Sulina Canal, on 13–14 November.
The Türkiye link runs both ways. Black Sea traffic passes through the Turkish Straits; if the coastal corridor premium approaches 2%, transit economics take a direct hit. If the same 2023 structure is applied to Turkish insurers' property treaties at 1 January, frequent losses will again stay on company balance sheets.
4 · The falsifier
Two developments would break this reading. If Howden, Aon, Gallagher Re or Guy Carpenter reports in the first week of January 2027 show attachment points coming down, structure has loosened too. If Allied World's aggregate Class A notes price below the 9% low end of guidance, frequency risk is moving to the capital markets. On the war side, a maritime ceasefire that brings quotes close to 2% would knock out that leg.
Probabilities
Scenarios
| Scenario | Probability | Trigger | Market impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| H1Price falls, structure holds | 60% | Property catastrophe rates fall about 10% at 1 January 2027 and attachment points renew at 2023 levels. | Frequent losses stay with primary insurers; their catastrophe burden in Europe remains high in 2027. |
| H2Competition brings attachment points down too | 30% | Abundant capital moves into lower layers and broker reports show a marked rise in frequency and aggregate cover. | Reinsurers' 2027 loss ratios deteriorate and hardening shifts to 2028; primary insurers' catastrophe burden eases. |
| H3Raphaela cuts the discount short | 10% | PERILS raises its Raphaela loss estimate well above 3.296 billion euros in its 28 November update. | Reinsurers limit price cuts in Europe and keep structure even tighter. |
Module A
Constraints Matrix
STRUCTURAL AVG 4.0 · TACTICAL AVG 2.7Structural constraints dominate: the outcome is set more by these limits than by the actors' preferences.
Hard structural constraintspersistent · beyond the actors' will
The 2023 attachment point
5/5Reinsurers raised the threshold in January 2023; Berenberg says holding it there is worth a 20–30% pricing advantage, two to three times the 10% discount at 1 January.
Limited appetite for frequency cover
4/5Reinsurers Berenberg met in September 2026 showed very limited appetite for frequency cover; Howden Re says they paid less than 25% of 2025 losses.
War premium threshold · Russia
4/5Beinsure says Black Sea premiums need to fall to 2% of hull value; quotes for Novorossiysk voyages have risen to 20%.
Physical ceiling on the state pool · Russia
3/5The Russian National Reinsurance Company can cover only 50–70 ships at a time; as export demand rises, that ceiling binds more tightly than the premium.
Tactical frictiontemporary · eases over time
Attacks on the coastal corridor days
3/5Four commercial ships were struck off the Sulina Canal on 13–14 November; corridor quotes of 0.4–1% on 9 November could be repriced.
Bargaining over terms weeks
3/5Munich Re's chief financial officer called 1 January a challenging renewal on 12 November; clients and brokers want changes to terms as well as price.
Raphaela loss update weeks
2/5PERILS' initial estimate is 3.296 billion euros; its 28 November update could change the size of the discount in Europe.
Module B
Signal vs Noise
SIGNAL 67% · NOISE 33%
- NOISE
Reinsurance is getting cheaper in every layer and the soft market is deepening
KBW expects property catastrophe excess-of-loss rates to fall at least 10% at 1 January; the decline was 12% in January 2026 and 16% at mid-year.
Insurance Business — Reinsurers face 10%+ cuts on Jan. 1. Their cat model checks are getting easier
- SIGNAL
Attachment points stay at 2023 levels; the discount does not reach structure
Berenberg says holding the threshold at 2023 levels is worth a 20–30% pricing advantage; reinsurers showed very limited appetite for frequency cover.
Actuary.info — Monte Carlo 2026: reinsurers cut price, hold frequency cover for 1.1.2027
- SIGNAL
Europe's frequent losses stayed on primary insurers' balance sheets
The catastrophe impact on Generali's combined ratio rose from 2.2 to 5.2 points over nine months; natural catastrophe losses totalled 1.47 billion euros.
- NOISE
The cat bond market is at a record pace and risk finds ample capital everywhere
The average spread fell 21.6% in a year to 5.05%, but 64% of 2026 issuance sits in the 1–3% expected-loss range, meaning remote layers.
- SIGNAL
On the war line the threshold is 2% and the quote 20%
War premiums on Novorossiysk voyages have risen to 20% of hull value; analysts point to 2% for a broad recovery, against 0.25–0.35% before 2022.
Data: Turkish Straits waiting time ›Beinsure — Black Sea war risk insurance premiums surge to 20% of vessel value
- SIGNAL
The one corridor below the threshold has been hit
Quotes for Romanian and Bulgarian transit were in a 0.4–1% band on 9 November; four commercial ships were struck by drones off the Sulina Canal on 13–14 November.
Euronews — Three commercial vessels struck by drones near Romania's Black Sea, PM says
Module C
Asset-Class and Positioning Implications
| Asset class | Exposure | Transmission channel | H1 | H2 | H3 | Expected | Conviction | Horizon | What to watch |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Freight & insurance | European household and commercial property insurance premiums | As frequent losses below the attachment point stay with primary insurers, they feed through to retail premiums | ++ | − | ++ | +1.10 | ●●● | 3–12 months | 2027 European commercial property renewal rates |
| Freight & insurance | Black Sea war-risk premiums and freight | Premiums staying above the 2% threshold make voyages uneconomic and add cost to freight | + | + | + | +1.00 | ●●● | 0–3 months | Quote band on the Romanian coastal corridor and Novorossiysk premiums |
| Credit | Cat bond risk spreads | Spreads tighten as capital keeps flowing to remote layers; a large loss would reverse the flow | − | − | + | −0.80 | ●●● | 0–3 months | Spread over expected loss in December issuance |
| Equities | European primary property insurance sector | Margins come under pressure while the catastrophe impact on the combined ratio stays high | − | + | − | −0.40 | ●●● | 3–12 months | Catastrophe points in February 2027 full-year results |
| Commodities | Black Sea grain export costs | War premiums add freight cost per tonne of grain and curb export volumes | + | + | + | +1.00 | ●●● | 0–3 months | Black Sea grain freight and Sulina transit data |
Second-order effects
And then what?
Starting point
The cat bond spread fell 21.6% in a year to 5.05%. KBW expects property catastrophe rates to fall at least 10% at 1 January, but attachment points remain at 2023 levels.
- 1
Reinsurance capacitywithin weeks
High policy rates boost the yield on cat bond collateral, keeping the average coupon at 7.14%. Capital flows to remote catastrophe layers; KBW says upper layers get cheaper at 1 January.
Watch: Price changes by layer in January 2027 broker renewal reports, and the Artemis fourth-quarter issuance report
- 2
Primary insurer balance sheetswithin months
This capital does not reach the frequency layer or war risk; primary insurers carry hail and flood losses below the attachment point, and shipowners carry war premiums of up to 20%.
Watch: The catastrophe impact on the combined ratio in Generali's and Zurich's full-year results in February 2027
- 3
Freight and goods costswithin months
Primary insurers pass the burden on to European household and commercial property premiums, and shipowners to freight. In the Black Sea, a 4-million-dollar premium adds about 67 dollars per tonne of grain.
Watch: 2027 European commercial property renewal rates and Black Sea grain freight
What breaks the chain
If January broker reports show attachment points coming down and the share of frequency cover rising markedly, or if policy rates fall quickly, the chain breaks at the first step.
Triggers
Thresholds to watch
| Indicator | Threshold | Today | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| US 10-year yield | < 3.5% | 5.10 | If front-end and intermediate yields fall, interest on cat bond collateral thins, capital flowing to remote layers slows and spread tightening may stop |
| Bosphorus transits | < 30 ships/day | — | If the war premium on the Black Sea coastal corridor approaches the 2% threshold, commercial transits through the Bosphorus could fall below this level |
Sources
- Actuary.info — Monte Carlo 2026: reinsurers cut price, hold frequency cover for 1.1.2027
- Reinsurance News — Generali's 9M'26 P&C operating result rises 4.5% despite higher cat and man-made losses
- Insurance Journal — Zurich Insurance says Europe storms drove catastrophe losses
- Reinsurance News — PERILS estimates initial insured losses of €3.296bn from SCS Raphaela
- Artemis — Cat bond market breadth expands, issuance concentrates in 1% to 3% EL range: Euler ILS Partners
- Artemis — California Earthquake Authority lowers pricing again for still $900m Ursa Re 2026-1 cat bond
- Artemis — Allied World targets $325m catastrophe bond renewal with 2001 CAT Re 2026-1 issuance
- Artemis — VKB lifts target to €200m for King Max Re German multi-peril cat bond renewal
- Insurance Business — Reinsurers face 10%+ cuts on Jan. 1. Their cat model checks are getting easier
- Reinsurance News — Jan 1 reinsurance renewal focus broadens beyond price: Munich Re CFO
- Beinsure — Black Sea war risk insurance premiums surge to 20% of vessel value
- ShipUniverse — 20% war-risk premiums: the Black Sea voyages that are becoming financially impossible
- Euronews — Three commercial vessels struck by drones near Romania's Black Sea, PM says
Sourcing and verification rules: methodology · Report an error: contact
Related reports
VIIReinsurance·Analysis·Middle East and North Africa
State guarantees cannot break Hormuz premiums because security is the constraint
France is negotiating a state-backed Hormuz insurance vehicle with the Gulf, yet the 40 billion dollar US guarantee had not written a single policy as of 17 May. Gulf war premiums run at 7–9%, against 0.15–0.25% before the war; claims and crew safety, not capacity, set the price.
Talay Insight Editorial · 15 November 2026 · 8 min
VIIReinsurance·Analysis·Europe
Reinsurers earn on yesterday's prices; new-business margin will decide January
Swiss Re and Hannover Re reported near-record nine-month profits, but the future profit pool on newly written P&C business shrank by 28% at Swiss Re and 11.9% at Hannover Re. That contraction, and the investment income masking it, will steer the 1 January 2027 renewal.
Talay Insight Editorial · 14 November 2026 · 8 min
VIIReinsurance·Analysis·Europe
Investment income floods catastrophe capacity as the war line narrows
Hannover Re's nine-month net investment income rose 40.4% to 1.9 billion euros. High rates are not driving reinsurers away from risk; they make cheaper catastrophe business bearable. The one line capacity avoids is war, where losses have overrun the annual budget.
Talay Insight Editorial · 13 November 2026 · 7 min