
III Kinetic Conflicts & DefenceSub-Saharan Africa
Amani Africa says Somalia and South Sudan are coups without soldiers
- Institution
- Amani Africa
- Author
- Institutional publication
- Country · language
- Ethiopia · English
- Affiliation
- Independent body based in Addis Ababa
Summary
In an unsigned piece published on 9 November, Addis Ababa-based Amani Africa puts the African Union's anti-coup norm to the test. It rests its case on Article 23(5) of the 2007 African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance. That provision also treats incumbents who amend the constitution to stay in office as an unconstitutional change of government. The argument is that the norm can be breached without a military coup, and that the AU Peace and Security Council should use its Article 7(1)(g) powers in both cases.
In Somalia the basis is a Supreme Court ruling of 5 November 2026. Five judges ruled unanimously that the 2026 constitutional amendments did not extend four-year terms of office. On that reading, parliament's mandate expired on 14 April and the federal government's on 15 May 2026. The court demanded an agreed electoral framework within 30 days and elections within 90. President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud rejected the ruling and announced he had replaced the chief justice; according to the piece, armed forces seized the court building.
In South Sudan, President Salva Kiir passed Constitutional Amendment No. 13 in September. On 22 September he dissolved the transitional government and the national and state legislatures by decree, and dismissed the first vice-president and 4 vice-presidents. Amani argues that these steps violate the consensus requirement in Article 1.9.4 of the 2018 peace agreement, which takes precedence over the constitution. Unless the AU treats both cases with the severity it applies to coups, it writes, the norm will lose credibility.
Blind spot
The piece concentrates on the legal framework and does not discuss the internal balance of power in the 2 capitals or whom the armed forces answer to. It gives contradictory dates, 2025 and 2026, for the adoption of Somalia's amendments. It does not weigh the AU's funding of its peacekeeping force in Somalia, or the military presence of the Gulf states and Türkiye in Mogadishu — in other words, the cost of sanctions.
Talay assessment
Bottom line
Amani's reading shows the African Union forced to rule on 2 separate cases at once. In Somalia the 5 November ruling has clarified the legal ground, but the Mogadishu government does not recognise the court. The most likely path is for the Council to settle for a call for mediation rather than a firm condemnation. For Türkiye, the risk is that its military and economic presence in Somalia becomes tied to a government of contested legitimacy.
Likely effects
- Somalia's election timetableNegative1–6 months
The court's 90-day deadline for elections falls in early February 2027; if the government fails to comply, the risk rises of the opposition returning to armed confrontation, as on 3 June.
- The African Union's normNegative6 months+
If the Council fails to apply Article 23(5) in both cases, the anti-coup norm becomes a selective tool that works only against military takeovers, strengthening the hand of the Sahel juntas.
- Türkiye's presence in SomaliaNegative1–6 months
Ankara's military and energy cooperation in Mogadishu is exposed to political risk because it continues with a government whose term is deemed to have expired on 15 May 2026.
Possibilities, ranked
- 1Mediation, not condemnation60%
The Council calls for dialogue and inclusive elections in both cases, and does not invoke its Article 7(1)(g) powers.
Watch: The Peace and Security Council's November–December agenda and final communiqué
- 2A negotiating table in Somalia25%
Within the court's 30-day window, the government and opposition begin talks on an electoral framework.
Watch: Announcement of a national consultative meeting in Mogadishu by 5 December
- 3Suspension on the agenda15%
The Council explicitly invokes Article 23(5) in at least 1 case and puts suspension or sanctions on the table.
Watch: The phrase 'unconstitutional change of government' appearing in a Council communiqué
Probabilities are calibrated judgement based on the sources, not measurement, and are revised as new information arrives. Not investment advice.
Original publication: amaniafrica-et.org · 14 November 2026
This page summarises the institution's view and does not reflect the view of Talay Insight. No direct quotation is used.