
III Kinetic Conflicts & DefenceAsia-Pacific
Shanghai institute says four-nation hub pushes Manila to the front line
- Institution
- Shanghai Institutes for International Studies (SIIS) — Global Times
- Author
- Li Kaisheng
- Country · language
- China · English
- Affiliation
- State-affiliated think tank
Summary
In a piece published on 12 November in the state outlet Global Times, SIIS vice-president Li Kaisheng criticises a new military mechanism set up in the Philippines. The defence ministers of the United States, Japan, Australia and the Philippines agreed to establish a Combined Coordination Centre on the sidelines of the ASEAN Defence Ministers' Meeting-Plus hosted by the Philippines. The centre is meant to coordinate the four countries' defence investment around the defence of the Philippine archipelago. Manila says the mechanism is already operating.
Li's thesis is that three outside powers are pushing the Philippines forward because none of them wants a direct clash with China. In his view, Washington wants to weaken China from its periphery, Japan wants to ease pressure in the East China Sea and Australia wants to block Beijing's ties in the South Pacific. In a conflict, he argues, the three would supply weapons and the Philippines would pay the price. Li contends that ASEAN has at least three other sovereignty disputes, yet only Manila extends its dispute to the whole of its relationship with China.
The author also links Manila's stance to domestic politics. In his view, the Marcos administration is heading towards the 2028 election with low approval ratings and presents its hard line on sovereignty as an achievement. Li further claims that Washington wields influence in Manila through family-based politics inherited from the colonial era. His prescription comes under three headings: governance, reliable energy supply and foreign investment in infrastructure.
Blind spot
The piece reads the Philippines' own security concerns purely as domestic politics and outside provocation. It never mentions Manila's case, which rests on the 2016 arbitration ruling and on maritime incidents at sea. It offers not a single figure for Marcos's approval rating. The claim of US influence through family politics is unsupported. Because it appeared in a state outlet, it should be read as close to Beijing's official line.
Talay assessment
Bottom line
This reading in a state outlet shows that Beijing sees the new four-nation centre as a leap in alliance-building and will direct its pressure at Manila rather than the partners. The emphasis on the 2028 election signals that China will make Philippine domestic politics a subject of debate. The most likely path is continued grey-zone encounters in the South China Sea, with the centre's operating timetable shaping Beijing's response.
Likely effects
- South China Sea securityNegative1–6 months
Coordinating four countries' defence investment through a single centre raises the likelihood that China steps up grey-zone pressure on Philippine resupply missions.
- Maritime trade and insuranceUncertain1–6 months
Bringing four countries under one roof does not on its own push war-risk premiums to a threshold; the constraint arises only if encounters spill over to merchant shipping.
- ASEAN balanceUncertain6 months+
Li's emphasis on three other sovereignty disputes shows that Beijing will try to isolate Manila within ASEAN.
Possibilities, ranked
- 1Rhetoric and grey-zone pressure60%
Beijing targets the centre diplomatically and keeps up pressure on resupply missions, but avoids direct military escalation.
Watch: The number of Chinese coast guard interventions against Philippine resupply missions and statements by China's foreign ministry
- 2Economic pressure kicks in25%
China imposes costs on Manila through restrictions on Philippine farm exports or tourism.
Watch: New inspections or restrictions by Chinese customs on Philippine banana and tropical fruit imports
- 3A maritime incident escalates15%
A collision or an incident with injuries sets off a debate over the US–Philippines Mutual Defense Treaty.
Watch: A China–Philippines incident in the South China Sea involving injuries or damage to a vessel
Probabilities are calibrated judgement based on the sources, not measurement, and are revised as new information arrives. Not investment advice.
Original publication: globaltimes.cn · 12 November 2026
This page summarises the institution's view and does not reflect the view of Talay Insight. No direct quotation is used.