
III Kinetic Conflicts & DefenceAsia-Pacific
Gateway House sees the Quad struggling to deliver amid US–China thaw
- Institution
- Gateway House (Mumbai)
- Author
- Rajiv Bhatia
- Country · language
- India · English
- Affiliation
- Independent think tank
Summary
Rajiv Bhatia, a former ambassador and foreign policy fellow at Gateway House, wrote about the Quad on 16 November. Leaders of the group, made up of the US, India, Japan and Australia, could have met in Manila on the sidelines of the 15–18 November ASEAN summit. The summit depended on Trump's attendance; had it gone ahead, it would have been the first Quad summit Trump attended. Leaders met 6 times between March 2021 and September 2024, 2 of them virtually.
The real work happens at ministerial level. Foreign ministers met 13 times between September 2019 and October 2026, 3 of them in 2026: New Delhi in May, Manila in July and Atlanta in October. The Delhi meeting produced 4 documents, including a critical minerals framework and an energy security statement. The Indo-Pacific Maritime Domain Awareness initiative also began in this period. Even so, Bhatia writes that since January 2025 the group has been generous with announcements and stingy with delivery.
In the author's view, the constraint is the rapprochement between Washington and Beijing. Trump and Xi have met in Busan, Beijing and Washington over the past 12 months, and the US is seeking 'strategic stability' with China. Trump will go from Manila to APEC in Shenzhen and host Xi at the G20 in Miami in mid-December. Rubio said in Atlanta on 31 October that the Quad is not anti-China. India and Australia want to protect the progress in their relations with China, while Japan–China relations are tense.
Blind spot
The piece measures success by whether the summit convenes and by the language of its statements. It does not say how many countries receive data from the maritime awareness initiative. Nor does it say which projects the critical minerals framework has funded; it offers no measurable indicator of delivery. How far India's own thaw with China has weakened the group appears only in a passing clause.
Talay assessment
Bottom line
Bhatia's reading presents the Quad not as a military alliance but as a political framework that depends on the 'strategic stability' Washington seeks with Beijing. Trump will meet Xi in Shenzhen straight after Manila and again in Miami in mid-December; that calendar limits the group's language on China. The most likely path is a repackaging of existing initiatives rather than new funding for maritime security and critical minerals.
Likely effects
- Maritime securityNegativeWeeks
As statements refer to China only implicitly, ASEAN states such as the Philippines will read the Quad's deterrence as weak and seek security through bilateral deals.
- Critical mineralsNegative1–6 months
If the Delhi framework does not turn into funded projects, the four countries' goal of reducing dependence on China stays on paper.
- IndiaPositive1–6 months
The US–China thaw gives Delhi room to keep its thaw with Beijing going while preserving the Quad; its multi-alignment policy becomes easier.
Possibilities, ranked
- 1Exercises yes, funding no55%
Military steps such as joint exercises with maritime patrol aircraft continue, but no funded critical minerals project emerges.
Watch: An announced date for a joint Quad exercise and budget allocated to the critical minerals framework
- 2Trump–Xi talks soften language30%
After the Shenzhen and Miami meetings, Washington drops the emphasis on 'economic coercion' from Quad statements.
Watch: Whether US statements after the Trump–Xi meeting in Shenzhen mention economic coercion
- 3Concrete delivery package15%
The maritime awareness initiative opens to new countries and a jointly funded critical minerals project is announced.
Watch: An official announcement widening the scope of the Indo-Pacific Maritime Domain Awareness initiative
Probabilities are calibrated judgement based on the sources, not measurement, and are revised as new information arrives. Not investment advice.
Original publication: gatewayhouse.in · 16 November 2026
This page summarises the institution's view and does not reflect the view of Talay Insight. No direct quotation is used.